• About the Blog
  • About the Wolfe

The Eagle Clawed Wolfe

~ Musing on Early Modern History

The Eagle Clawed Wolfe

Monthly Archives: March 2013

Aural History Part I- Sharing a car with Macaulay, Bragg and Beard.

10 Sunday Mar 2013

Posted by Grant in Uncategorized

≈ 8 Comments

Tags

Macaulay, Mary Beard, Media, Podcasts

Due to changing jobs a few months ago, my rail commute into London with its opportunity to read and write-up my thoughts has been replaced by a drive down to obscure parts of Surrey, rather  to the detriment of this blog. However this does give me a couple of hours per day with no demands on my time from family or employers in which to get some intellectual stimulus and the historical podcast has been an epiphany to me. I thought I’d share my thoughts on some of these podcasts and casters over an article or two.

The podcast is a loose term- and one I use more loosely than most- as any piece of recorded speech downloaded from the internet. As we will see this embraces a broad church of recordings.

On of the most common sources is radio programmes repackaged  as podcasts. These, of course, benefit from far better production values than a chap with a mic in his office. Whilst this also means that there has to be a big enough audience for the subject  to be commissioned, which rules out the most obscure and recherché we are very lucky in having Radio 4 with its public service brief delivers some superb stuff.

Bragg's "In Our Time"

Bragg’s “In Our Time”

My favourite, and the backbone of my listening has been In Our Time. This has been running for donkey’s years and the entire archive is available on podcast. In these, unedited 45 minute programmes, Melvyn Bragg hosts three, often quite prominent, academics to discuss a given topic in science, philosophy, history or literature. Bragg, informed by notes from this guests, (and frequently his own prejudices) guides and referees the discussion. Now whether you enjoy these or not depends a lot on how you feel about Bragg- and a lot of people I know take strong exception to him. I think he does a rather good job of courting or suppressing disagreement as required, moving the academics on from dwelling on their hobby-horse topics and keeping the show within its time limits. Un-scripted (or, at best loosely scripted) as they are they vary in quality somewhat, some really come off and others are less successful but few fall really flat. They are nicely weighted to please the completely layman whilst still having something for the informed amateur but the beauty of them is their variety. How else could you , in one week listen to expert views on The Norman Yoke, The Peterloo Massacre, the Boxer Rebellion, Octavia Hill, The Volga Vikings, Caxton, The Borgias, the Condordat of Wormes and the Seige of Munster?

 Although I have no pretence at all of being a classicist, I will admit to being a devotee of Mary Beard and her short contributions to another Radio 4 Production, A Point of View are worth a listen. There is a lot to admire about her. Her conscious defiance of the convention that TV historians should either be distinguished middle-aged men or pretty young women is perhaps slightly dated, but her determination to be herself is refreshing. Her TV delivery seems lighthearted and almost naive with her smirking references to willies and coitus. Although her undyed hair and eccentric dress may be very much her own she does sometimes make an affectation of not being affected . However I enjoy the personal nature of her histories and there is always a hard intelligent core to all she does. Her recent series on Rome had some real nuggets of social commentary without being heavy handed. Despite her mildness and clear compassion he has, of course also sparked a couple of significant controversies. After September 11th her soundbite about America “having it coming” was, if not exactly out of context, certainly more palatable when framed as part of her more nuanced argument. She recently raised ire again by questioning the veracity of locals complaints about the effect of immigration on rural Lincolnshire. I happen to think that she may not have been entirely right here and that she might have allowed her instinctive liberalism to dismiss a genuine issue. However her exposition of the malice and misogyny on twitter and forums which were a  consequence of her comments further demonstrated to me her integrity and steel. Her contributions to Point of View on such subjects as the modern age and beauty, death in Pompeii, the age of consent, poverty and academia are studied, engaging and poignant and exemplifies how valuable a historical perspective from a first class on modern social issues can be.

Lord Macaulay Whig and Scholar

Lord Macaulay Whig and Scholar

Another revelation, and one which has been an absolute joy, was the discovery that the whole of Macaulay’s History of England from the Accession of James II is available on podcast. This is not the place to dissect the merits of Macaulay, so I will try to limit my enthusiasm and only do so briefly. We are taught that we ought to rather dismiss Macaulay as his Victorian Whig perspective of the perfection of the English constitution and the perhaps slightly unfair perception that he believed that this was determined by fate due to some inherrent virtue of the English and Anglicanism are considered oversimplified, wrong and, worse quaint. This is maybe true, but to discount him like this is to do him- and yourself- a great disservice as it is wonderful stuff. He writes beautifully, with a verve, authority and even tenderness which few modern writers can match. If the thread of his narrative doesn’t stand up to modern scholarship (or indeed near contemporary Marx was not a fan to say the least) it betrays his bias not his lack of insight or analysis which is thought provoking even now.

The online recordings are by LibriVox, an organisation of volunteers which makes public domain reading of out of copyright books and it is credit to them to have taken on the huge 5 volume history. It also gives the recording a rather different character to a professional recording would. Instead of the middle aged,male received pronunciation you would expect, segments are read by a variety of the volunteers from around the world. I actually rather like it, although some of the American renderings of some English place names was a bit off (Charles lost at Nas-er-by we are told), and hearing the Sun King referred to as “Lewis” grated a bit, only one reader with a heavy Indian accent actually made understanding difficult. I’m getting through about a chapter per week or so the whole work will be a project of several months, but what a pleasure it is. I particularly enjoy the reading of Chip from Tampa and the anonymous Yorkshireman who do much or the early reading but the change of voices from around the English speaking world and of both sexes is perhaps no bad think for such a long piece.

LibriVox has an extensive catalogue of fiction and non-fiction, including G.K. Chesterton’s (considerably briefer)  History of England, and they are working on David Hume’s (almost equally long) opus – which I may even contribute to. It is a brilliant completely free resource which I’m nor sure many people realise is there.

I’ll write a couple more of these in the near future, hopefully interspersed with some actual posts on history. I hope you’ll reign me in if you find I am regressing into Whiggishness due to saturation in Macaulay.

 

Recent Posts

  • When is the “Other House” not a “Senate”? What Cicero and Cromwell can teach Ed Miliband
  • Obedience to Lawful Orders : Macaulay, Glencoe, Afganistan and Iraq
  • The Independent Scholar- Italian Voices and Desperately Seeking EEBO
  • Apologies
  • Starkey’s “Tudors and Us”- Sex and the Reformation Come to Maidenhead

Archives

  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • July 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • June 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012

55 Days A.N.Wilson Age Arbella Stuart Army Bess of Hardwick Birkbeck Books Border Reivers Charles I Civil War Constitution David Starkey Domestic Violence Dumbarton's Regiment Economics Ed Miliband EEBO Elizabeth I England Enrico Dandolo Eric Hobsbawm Fifteenth Century Flodden Florence France Glencoe Henry VIII Heraldry Hilary Mantel House of Lords Italy JSTOR Lawful Orders Louis XIV Louis XVI Macaulay Mary Beard Media Medieval National Debt Newspapers Nuremberg Old Age Oliver Cromwell Other House Parliament Phineas Pett Podcasts Prince Rupert Race Review Richard III Roman Republic Scandal Scotland Senate Seventeenth Century Shipbuilding Sir John Forster Sir John Reresby Sixteenth Century Slavery Television Test Acts Theatre The Wolfe Thomas Howard Trials Tudors Twelfth Century Venice William Hepworth Thompson William III Women

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.com

Blog Stats

  • 11,798 hits

License

Creative Commons Licence
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License

Blogroll

  • British Army Lineages
  • Gentlemen and Tarpaulins
  • Long Lost Railways
  • Mercurius Politicus
  • Ready to wear (1640s style)
  • Saxon Fencing Club
  • The 1640s Picture Book
  • The Secret History of the Sword

Other Links

  • Birkbeck, University of London
  • King Cricket

Blog at WordPress.com.

Cancel
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy